- Joined
- Jan 6, 2023
- Messages
- 279
- Reaction score
- 112
- Points
- 43
I'm quite curious about this black compound that appears when hydrochloride heated.
Considering it behaviour (getting black while heated) I always thought it is carbon, but I don't understand how it gets in the solution in such huge amount.
Let's check this guess empirically.
When I do base extraction, I often see the same thing: black base descends below water layer.
For example, I want extract base from 300 gr of hydrochloride. For the beginning I use about 500-600 ml of water. I add around 85 gr of NaOH, and see what I said before; base appears at the bottom.
Now I need to add about 10-15 gr of NaCl per 100 ml of water to move it up.
Let's calculate a bit.
600 ml of water - 600 gr, 600 cm3, density - 1.0 gr/cm3
15 gr of salt x 6 = 90 gr, 41 cm3, density - 2.17 gr/cm3
Final density of this water NaCl solution is 1.07 (I even don't count NaOH leftovers!!!, that shall increase density even more).
It means, density of FB layer shall be around 1.05 gr/cm3.
As people believe, density of base itself is around 0.9.
Let's approach this data for carbon.
Carbon has molar volume 5.3 cm3/mole, that points on density 2.26 gr/cm3.
So, if base - carbon mixture is in proportions 90:10, then density shall be 0.9 * 90% + 2.26 * 10% = 1.04 gr/cm3 - pretty close to the numbers I said before.
Such calculation can explain this phenomenon, but for me it is too much weird to get such huge amount of carbone while product heated. It is also strange for me that carbon mixes with base.
Or, may be, there is some other explanation?
Considering it behaviour (getting black while heated) I always thought it is carbon, but I don't understand how it gets in the solution in such huge amount.
Let's check this guess empirically.
When I do base extraction, I often see the same thing: black base descends below water layer.
For example, I want extract base from 300 gr of hydrochloride. For the beginning I use about 500-600 ml of water. I add around 85 gr of NaOH, and see what I said before; base appears at the bottom.
Now I need to add about 10-15 gr of NaCl per 100 ml of water to move it up.
Let's calculate a bit.
600 ml of water - 600 gr, 600 cm3, density - 1.0 gr/cm3
15 gr of salt x 6 = 90 gr, 41 cm3, density - 2.17 gr/cm3
Final density of this water NaCl solution is 1.07 (I even don't count NaOH leftovers!!!, that shall increase density even more).
It means, density of FB layer shall be around 1.05 gr/cm3.
As people believe, density of base itself is around 0.9.
Let's approach this data for carbon.
Carbon has molar volume 5.3 cm3/mole, that points on density 2.26 gr/cm3.
So, if base - carbon mixture is in proportions 90:10, then density shall be 0.9 * 90% + 2.26 * 10% = 1.04 gr/cm3 - pretty close to the numbers I said before.
Such calculation can explain this phenomenon, but for me it is too much weird to get such huge amount of carbone while product heated. It is also strange for me that carbon mixes with base.
Or, may be, there is some other explanation?